Illustration of a chicken and leek pie with a golden puff-pastry lid and loose creamy filling spooned onto a plate

Recipe

Chicken and Leek Pie

Published 09 October 2026 · Updated 25 October 2026

Chicken and leek pie with tender chicken pieces in a creamy mustard sauce beneath crisp puff pastry. Browning adds flavour, while thickening the sauce and cooling the filling before assembly helps the pastry stay crisp.

Not kitchen tested by The Black Farmer.
Serves 6
Prep 55 min
Cook 86 min
Total 146 min

Timing: Allow about 146 minutes for the pie: 30 minutes active preparation, 25 minutes cooling, 86 minutes cooking and 5 minutes resting. The first 20 minutes of preparation include washing and cutting vegetables, cutting chicken, stripping thyme, measuring the sauce ingredients and checking equipment. Oven heating takes place alongside this same 20-minute preparation window and is not added again; leave the oven on afterwards. A separate 10 minutes of preparation covers rolling, assembling, venting and glazing after cooling. The 86-minute cooking budget comprises 2 minutes pan heating, 15 minutes browning in three batches, 10 minutes softening vegetables, 1 minute garlic, 1 minute flour, 5 minutes adding stock and thickening, 12 minutes returning to a simmer and cooking the chicken, and 40 minutes baking. Each 30-second thermometer hold is included in its parent cooking stage, not an additional wait. This schedule is for a freshly cooked filling cooled only as directed, not a refrigerated or frozen pie. Cooling, oven recovery and safe doneness depend on equipment and room conditions; allow longer if the stated cues are not reached. Accompaniments are not included.

Ingredients

Adds 1 items across 1 products — £29.30 total.

Pantry ingredients such as oil, salt and herbs are not included.

Other Ingredients You'll Need

  • Onion — 1 medium (about 150g peeled), thinly sliced
  • Garlic — 2 cloves, finely chopped
  • Neutral oil — 2 tbsp, divided: 1 tbsp between the three chicken batches and 1 tbsp for the vegetables
  • Fine salt and black pepper — to taste
  • Fresh thyme — 4 sprigs, leaves stripped and woody stalks discarded
  • Chicken stock — 300ml, preferably reduced-salt
  • Leek — 2 medium-large (about 400g trimmed), washed thoroughly and sliced into 5mm half-moons (Use the white and pale-green parts; discard roots and tough dark-green tops. The trimmed weight is a recipe target, not a shop pack claim.)
  • Puff pastry — 500g chilled block, for a lid only (Roll to approximately 36 x 28cm and 4mm thick to cover the specified dish; trim the excess. Do not line the dish.)
  • Plain flour — 30g for the sauce, plus a little for dusting the worktop
  • Crème fraîche — 100g, full-fat
  • Wholegrain mustard — 1 tbsp
  • Egg — 1 medium, beaten for sealing and glazing

Method

Prepare the ingredients and heat the oven

Allow 20 minutes for this preparation, with oven heating alongside it. Set the oven to 200°C, or 180°C fan, gas 6; leave it on ready for baking. Use a deep ovenproof pie dish of at least 3 litres, approximately 30 x 22cm inside at the top and 6cm deep, with an outside rim no larger than 32 x 24cm, plus a baking tray. Check its capacity before cooking if unsure. Have a 30cm wide, deep frying pan and two shallow heatproof containers ready. Trim, split lengthways, wash between the layers and slice the leek into 5mm half-moons; aim for about 400g trimmed from the two leeks. Slice the onion, chop the garlic, strip the thyme leaves and measure the stock, crème fraîche, mustard and 30g flour. Cut the chicken into 3cm pieces, pat dry and season lightly with salt and black pepper. Wash hands, board and utensils after handling raw chicken. Keep the pastry chilled until assembly.

Brown the chicken in three batches

Heat the empty frying pan over a medium-high heat for 2 minutes. Divide 1 tbsp of the oil between three batches of chicken, roughly 330g per batch. Brown each batch for 5 minutes, turning to colour several sides, then transfer to a plate; allow 15 minutes for all three batches. Keep the pieces in a single layer with space between them so they sear rather than steam. They should have golden patches but need not be cooked through yet; they will finish in the sauce. Keep the juices on the plate for the filling.

Soften the leek and onion

Reduce the hob to medium-low. Add the remaining 1 tbsp oil, the leek and onion, and a small pinch of salt. Cook for 10 minutes, stirring and scraping up the chicken juices, until the vegetables are soft and the onion is translucent, without dark browning. Stir in the garlic and cook for 1 minute until fragrant.

Thicken the mustard sauce

Scatter over the 30g plain flour and stir for 1 minute over a medium-low heat so no dry patches remain. Over the next 5 minutes, gradually stir in the 300ml chicken stock, scraping the base and stirring out lumps; bring to a gentle simmer and cook until the sauce thickens. Stir in the crème fraîche, wholegrain mustard and stripped thyme leaves. The sauce should coat a spoon rather than look like broth.

Cook the chicken through

Return the chicken and all its plate juices to the sauce. Allow 12 minutes over a medium heat to return to a gentle simmer and cook, stirring regularly and reducing the heat once bubbling so it does not catch. The chicken must be cooked through before cooling: use a clean food thermometer in several of the largest pieces, including those in the centre of the pan, and check that they reach 75°C for at least 30 seconds. Include this check in the cooking stage; cook longer if needed. The sauce should cling thickly to the chicken, without a pool of watery liquid. If loose, continue simmering uncovered until it coats the spoon thickly; the cue takes priority over the estimated time. Taste only once the chicken is cooked, then adjust salt and black pepper.

Cool the filling before adding pastry

Divide the cooked filling between the two shallow heatproof containers, spreading it out rather than leaving it in the deep pan. Allow about 25 minutes to cool, stirring occasionally, until warm rather than hot and no longer giving off visible steam. Leave the pastry in the fridge and the oven on during this stage. Do not cover hot filling with pastry; allow longer cooling if it is still steaming. This method goes straight from this short cooling stage to assembly and baking, not into a make-ahead refrigerator or freezer branch.

Roll, seal and glaze the lid

Allow 10 minutes for assembly. Spoon the cooled filling into the 3-litre pie dish, leaving at least 2cm clear below the rim; do not use the former 1.5-litre dish. Lightly dust the worktop with plain flour. Roll the 500g puff pastry block to approximately 36 x 28cm and 4mm thick, keeping the layers even. It must extend beyond the dish's outside rim on every side. Brush the rim lightly with beaten egg, lift the pastry over the filling and press it onto the rim without stretching. Trim to a small overhang and crimp to seal. There is no pastry base. Cut two slits through the lid near the centre to release steam, then brush the top with beaten egg, avoiding the exposed cut edges so they can rise. Discard unused raw egg glaze. Put the dish on the baking tray.

Bake until crisp and hot in the centre

Bake on the middle shelf for about 40 minutes at 200°C, or 180°C fan, gas 6, until the lid is well risen, deep golden and crisp, with sauce bubbling through the vents. Check near the end of this stage with a clean food thermometer through a vent: the centre of the filling and several large chicken pieces there should reach 75°C for at least 30 seconds. Edge bubbles alone do not prove the centre is hot. Continue baking if needed to meet both pastry and centre-temperature cues, covering the top loosely with foil if it is browning too quickly. The thermometer check is included in the baking allowance; the safe endpoint takes priority over the clock.

Rest and serve

Rest the pie for 5 minutes before serving. Divide the lid into six portions and spoon the creamy filling underneath each portion; this is a lid-only pie, not a firm slice with a pastry base. Serve with peas or steamed greens. The filling will still be hot.

Serving Suggestion

Serve with peas or steamed greens to balance the rich filling; the pastry already provides the starchy part of the meal.

Frequently Asked Questions

Why does the filling need to cool before I add the pastry?

Hot filling releases steam and softens the pastry before it reaches the oven. Spread the cooked filling in shallow containers and use the warm, non-steaming cue in the method before fitting the lid. Keep the pastry cold until then so its layers have a better chance to rise.

Does this pie have a pastry base?

No. The pastry makes a crisp lid over a creamy filling, so serve it by spooning rather than expecting a self-supporting slice. Use the chilled block and rolling dimensions in the method; a single smaller ready-rolled sheet may not cover the larger dish.

Why use a larger dish for this filling?

A kilo of chicken plus two leeks, onion and sauce needs room beneath the lid. Use the stated dish of at least 3 litres and leave the headroom given in the method. Nominal dish capacities vary, so check both capacity and rim measurements rather than relying on diameter alone.